DOGE cuts show how smaller government can harm economy

Published on:

Introduction to the Impact of Government Shutdown on Real Estate

As the U.S. begins its first federal government shutdown since 2018, with uncertain repercussions for the economy, the effects of government budget cuts continue to rattle real estate markets across the U.S. Even though former government officials are no longer in office, their legacy remains, with one of the lasting impacts being the cancellation of hundreds of government leases across the country.

According to the DOGE website, 384 leases have been cancelled, with estimated savings of roughly $140 million. However, experts argue that these savings come at a broader economic cost. Cameron LaPoint, assistant professor of finance in the Yale School of Management, has studied the impact of government closures on the commercial real estate market and points out that the government, as a tenant, used to be a very safe bet.

Understanding the Economic Impact

LaPoint explains that because government leases often included cancellation clauses that rarely were invoked, landlords are now left high and dry. This is happening in cities large and small, rural and urban, across the country. “A lot of private landlords are renting space out to government agencies, and they were counting on these agencies being in their space paying rent for five years. Now landlords have to find new tenants,” LaPoint added.

The savings touted by DOGE are largely based on the assumption that the government would have renewed the leases when they expired, but the numbers aren’t factoring in that some leases naturally wouldn’t be renewed due to normal government downsizing or relocations. It may not seem like a few hundred lease cancellations could send a jolt through the country’s financial system, but lease cancellations do have a ripple effect.

Commercial Lending Market Implications

“The multiplication effects can be tied to thousands of loans across the country the way the commercial debt market works,” LaPoint said. Government leases provide stable, predictable income that makes them attractive to lenders. When these “anchor tenants” disappear, it doesn’t just affect the buildings — it can destabilize the broader commercial lending market because banks package these property loans together into investment securities.

A spokeswoman for the General Services Administration, which manages federal assets, said it has achieved notable results in a short time as it optimizes the federal portfolio, and estimated the savings to American taxpayers at $113 million. However, experts like Alexi Morgado, realtor and CEO of Lexawise, based in Florida, are seeing the effects of cancelled federal leases developing into a chain reaction in a number of markets.

Regional Impacts and Mitigation Strategies

Morgado notes, “The availability of supply does not always lead to immediate demand, putting strain on operating income and building values, which can complicate financing.” The top three agency tenants with cancelled leases are the Social Security Administration, the Small Business Administration, and the Geological Survey. The impact can be uneven by geography, with some areas feeling the pressure more than others.

Mark Besharaty, senior vice president of commercial lending at California-based Arbor Financial Group, agrees that landlords of now-vacant government office space will need to get creative. “To mitigate what I see happening in most cases, the owners of these properties will have to reconfigure the properties to fit a different kind of tenant base,” Besharaty said. Mitigation measures include subdividing larger government offices into smaller, more manageable parcels so other businesses can move in.

Rural America and the Shutdown

Rural properties with cancelled government leases face more acute risk because they typically aren’t included in those bundled loan packages, but that also means they have less financial cushioning when major tenants leave. Rural, less populated counties could also be at heightened risk of federal lease cancellations going forward. LaPoint noted that among federal leases that are potentially on the chopping block, 57% are located outside the 10 most populated states and outside of Washington, D.C.

Tom Whalen, professor and department chair of business administration at Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts, says the whole issue of lease cancellation costs is nuanced. “You could say it harkens back to John Maynard Keynes and his idea that the government can stimulate the economy through spending. Similarly, when the government withdraws funds from the economy, economic activity will contract,” Whalen said, and he added that there is a multiplier effect.

Conclusion and Further Insights

Prediction markets are currently betting that the shutdown lasts two weeks. The Trump administration has threatened that more federal workers could be fired as a consequence of a shutdown. Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vought told House Republicans during a conference call after the shutdown began that the Trump administration will carry out reductions in force among federal workers in one or two days.

For more information on how the government shutdown and budget cuts may impact the economy, visit Here

Smart Tip for Readers

When considering the economic impact of government shutdowns and lease cancellations, it’s essential to look beyond the immediate savings and consider the broader effects on local economies and the commercial lending market. Staying informed about these issues can help individuals and businesses prepare for potential economic shifts and make more informed decisions about investments and financial planning.

Latest News

Leave a Reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here